Welcome to Dimaggio's Pizza
Welcome to Dimaggio's Pizza, a beloved gem nestled in Carmi, IL. Our story is one of passion for crafting exceptional pizza that transcends local expectations. Not just another pizzeria, Dimaggio's offers a unique blend of cozy bar vibes and culinary excellence, making every pie a masterpiece. We pride ourselves on our sweet, saucy recipes and diverse vegetarian options, appealing to all palates. With comfortable seating for groups and a cozy atmosphere perfect for families, we are dedicated to creating memorable dining experiences. For four decades, we have welcomed locals and travelers alike, making every visit a celebration of flavor and community.
Dimaggio's Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Sure it's the only spot in a small town, but Dimaggios is special. It's got that bar pizza vibe but taken up a level to legitimate perfect pie territory. I'm a sucker for sweet saucy pizza and Dimaggios delivers
I love this pizza, and I'm getting ready to order it now! Can order made or premade. I love out of town so I'll get premade and store in freezer.
Some of the best Pizza ever much better than Pizza Hut or any fast food pizza. And there Calzones are wonderful and so is there breadsticks. The people who gave 2 and 1 stars have bad taste buds.
Food is good, but took a while for food delivery and when the food was delivered the kid had two girls in the truck with him, Idk if he was training them or not. I probably will do pick up if I order from there again because of the delivery wait time is awful. This was not on a holiday or peek weekend days.
Wonderful place. A local favorite! Have been a regular for 40 years! If passing through give it a try!
I have to say that moving to the small town of Carmi I was a bit disappointed with the lack of available restaurants. What a surprise when I ordered from Dimaggio's. This pizza was so delicious - I nearly cried for joy. great family owned place
I measure all other pizza I eat by this pizza here. The crust is thin and crispy, a mouthwatering sweet sauce and amazing variety of toppings. DiMaggio's is by far the very best pizza I have ever eaten in my entire life. This was the first pizza I remember eating as a kid and 40 years later, it is still unmatched. DiMaggio's have several restaurants in Southern Illinois but the Carmi site still bakes the best pizza. I live in Florida now but still make it a point to stop by when I'm back home. I just can't say enough good things about this place!!
Location
-
100 April Ave Carmi, IL 62821 Hotline: (618) 382-8912
Welcome to Dimaggio's Pizza, a gem nestled in the heart of Carmi, Illinois. This beloved establishment has carved out a special place in the local dining scene, attracting pizza aficionados and casual diners alike. Conveniently located at 100 April Ave, Dimaggio's is not just a restaurant; it's a community hub where flavors and memories come together.
From the moment you step inside, the warm ambiance invites you to relax and enjoy your meal. Whether you're here for lunch, dinner, or a late-night bite, Dimaggio's offers a wide array of options that cater to every palate. Their menu features an impressive selection of pizzas, with many vegetarian choices ensuring everyone can find something delightful. As one loyal customer, Kari M., put it, it's a "wonderful place" that has captivated locals for over 40 years.
- Reservations and Convenience: Dimaggio's makes dining easy and accessible. The restaurant welcomes reservations and offers delivery and takeout, accommodating busy schedules and last-minute cravings.
- Pizzas with Personality: Reviewers rave about the "sweet saucy pizza" that draws you in with its rich flavors. The crust is perfectly cooked to a golden crisp that holds the toppings without faltering—a perfect base for the unique sauces.
- Families Welcome: The atmosphere is notably kid-friendly and ideal for groups. Given the moderate noise level and outdoor seating, it's the perfect spot for gatherings or casual family dinners.
- Catering Options: For those special events or parties, Dimaggio's offers catering services, delivering their delightful pizzas straight to your doors.
- Extras that Elevate: Aside from mouthwatering pizzas, Dimaggio's also serves incredible calzones and breadsticks, which are favorites among regulars like Ethan's u., who can't get enough of these tasty side dishes.
However, a few customers have mentioned waiting times for delivery; yet the consensus is clear: once you taste the food, you’ll understand why. As Rosa C. shared, if you can, opt for pick-up to sidestep any delay and savor your dish fresh out of the kitchen. Dimaggio's commitment to quality and flavor is unmistakable, which makes the wait worthwhile.
If you’re looking for a taste of authentic pizza that combines tradition with local flair, Dimaggio's Pizza is your destination. Every slice is a testament to the love and expertise poured into this establishment. Stop by or call them at (618) 382-8912, and experience a slice of what makes this spot a cherished local favorite.
